The Gold Scab

Dave and I were at the de Young Museum on Sunday afternoon. I haven’t been there more than once or twice in my life, and probably not in well over a decade; Dave, on the other hand, has been there many times throughout his life (he grew up in the Bay Area), and he’s familiar with a lot of the collection.

I could only vaguely remember anything in the museum, and it was a bit of a shock to me to come across an oil painting by Whistler that I didn’t remember ever seeing before and couldn’t remember knowing anything about, The Gold Scab. But when I pointed it out to Dave, it turned out the painting was an old acquaintance for him.

I was surprised at myself for not knowing about this painting. Whistler is one of my favorite painters, and his Peacock Room at the Freer Gallery in Washington, D.C., is one of my favorite places. Whistler painted the room for his patron Frederick Leyland, but as the work progressed, the two men quarreled increasingly bitterly over it, and over how much Leyland should pay Whistler for it. Even after they’d finally agreed on a fee, Leyland shaved shillings off it as a deliberate insult. They never reconciled after that.

Arrangement in Black: Portrait of F. R. Leyland, by James Whistler The banner at the top of this blog is adapted from the mural Whistler painted on one wall of the room. The peacock on the left represents Whistler himself, and it is fleering at the peacock on the right, who represents Leyland. Leyland’s peacock has silver shillings in among its gold breast feathers, has silver shillings in place of eyes in its tail feathers, and is standing on a pile of gold coins and silver shillings. (The whole wild story is both sad and funny, and the loss of Leyland’s patronage was a self-inflicted blow to Whistler’s finances that he never recovered from.)

As I said, I couldn’t remember having even heard of The Gold Scab before, though I checked my books when I got back home and it’s definitely mentioned; I’d just forgotten it. But I immediately recognized the painting as a cruel caricature of Leyland — the fact that he looks like a man in a peacock suit decorated with gold coins is an obvious giveaway to anyone who knows the story of the Peacock Room, and I remembered what the man looked like from Whistler’s full-length portrait of him. Evidently Whistler wasn’t content with having painted his contempt for Leyland on the man’s own dining room wall, but had to produce an additional three oil paintings mocking him, of which only this one is known to have survived.

6 thoughts on “The Gold Scab

  1. I should add that although I was quite familiar with the old De Young museum, this was our first outing to the newly remodeled museum 2.0 (which was not so newly, given that reopening was in October 2005). So although various pieces were definitely old friends, they were being seen in completely new contexts.

  2. Last weekend my husband and I were at the Freer Gallery and had the reverse experience from the one that you describe. The Gold Scab has long been a favorite of mine at the DeYoung. As we sat in front of Leyland’s portrait at the Freer, we put together the story of the Peacock Room, the portrait in front of us, and the Gold Scab. It was great to read your similar story.

  3. i was at the ‘new’ De Young Sunday and was very, very taken with this painting (haven’t been to the museum in a long time, either . . . was my first outing to the ‘new’ museum except a brief excursion to the ‘quilts from the South’ exhibition . . . ) . . . had to look up online – was sure someone knew the story – and then there’s the funny misspelling of ‘filthy’ . . . i was utterly entranced! . . .

  4. Was at the “new” De Young today, and like b shafer above, was totally taken by this painting. I had to look up some history about it, and was pointed in the direction of this page. I also noticed the misspelling of ‘filthy’ while gazing at the painting, and couldn’t help but think of the title of the Sex Pistols reunion tour. Yes, ‘The Filth Lucre Tour’.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s